“The previous can hang-out a person” is the primary superficially “Reminiscence” melancholic line that will get muttered in “Memory,” a moody, snail-paced mixture of neo-noir and sci-fi, overflowing with equally vague wisdom about time and nostalgia. It does aptly outline the tone for “Westworld” co-creator Lisa Joy’s narrative characteristic debut as an author/director, nonetheless. Set someday sooner or later alongside the Miami coast—now, devastated by local weather change and partially sunken, with a modified model of life nonetheless persisting on its belt nocturnally since days are simply too scorching—“Memory” goals for one thing existential inside a well-recognized film-noir template. Sadly, the result’s an unpersuasive, vaguely pessimistic dystopia at greatest, one which liberally pulls 101-level references from recognizable Hitchcock flicks and neo-noirs alike, solely to drown their time-honored spirit in murky waters.
Certainly, you’ll spot cues from the likes of “Chinatown,” “Blade Runner,” “Strange Days” and even “Minority Report” all through Pleasure’s style entry that culminates in a deeply acquainted aura. And whereas that simple-minded accessibility doesn’t essentially should be a foul factor, “Memory” does so little that is unique or homage-y with its mélange. Pleasure’s movie simply feels so frustratingly generic and second-hand, that includes physique doubles and a dizzying spiral staircase that serve no objective apart from telegraphing “Vertigo”-Esque visible prompts to the viewer for no narrative or aesthetic cause.
Hugh Jackman’s Nick Bannister occurs to be the murmurer of the aforesaid line concerning the previous’s haunting powers. He delivers it via a morose voiceover (one of many many grating overindulgences of “Memory”), introducing his unconventional career to the viewer within the movie’s opening moments. Nick is a non-public eye who will get to research the depths of his shoppers’ recollections—generally, to reply an easy query, however typically instances, to permit them to relive their favorite moments from the previous. He and his fellow ex-military enterprise associate Watts (Thandiwe Newton, extra emotionally affecting than her one-note half can deal with) appear to have a superb, platonic factor entering into a world the place the long run provides no hope and previous is the one avenue that comes with jolts of optimism buried inside. Whereas the duo gives freebees to repeat clients typically, they nonetheless handle making a dwelling with their reminiscence machine—a cocoon mattress and a wired headpiece that performs and initiatives any reminiscence the shopper chooses from stashes of discs, as a 3D hologram. Romantic, empowering, peaceable … there’s one thing for everybody.
So when the resident femme fatale of “Memory” arrives within the type of Rebecca Ferguson’s sultry, markedly unhappy jazz singer Mae, clad in a spectacular, body-conscious crimson-red robe that might disarm any deadly human in its presence, she received to be as much as any good. With misty, Lauren Bacall-Esque mannerisms, Mae insists to pop into the machine briefly previous the ability’s closing time. She’s misplaced her keys, you see, and hopes that Watts and Bannister may simply retrieve them via a fast peek into her thoughts. Forgive this try to hunt real-world logic inside a fantasy, however, this request appears to go in opposition to every little thing “Memory” claims to determine about how human thoughts makes and shops recollections. If Mae hasn’t paid consideration to the second when she misplaced them and may recall the whereabouts of her keys, how may a reminiscence of it exist in her thoughts? And shouldn’t this suspicious request alarm Nick Bannister directly?
Let’s blame his distraction on that purple robe (and varied different gorgeous night frocks Ferguson wears all through “Memory”). She finds her keys alright, and the 2 quickly sufficient embark on a steamy romance, on the heels of a legitimately erotic intercourse scene Pleasure tastefully pulls off with inventive finesse. However, Mae disappears into skinny air months later, leaving Nick and Watts with nothing however a handful of clues and recollections they will maintain onto, with a purpose to keep afloat in a sunken maze of bigwig criminals, corrupt cops, and barons who’ve mapped out their survival on the dry land.
Reuniting with a number of her artisan collaborators from “Westworld,” Pleasure renders this hope-starved near-future world with heavy use of neon lights and shadows, attaining a melancholic high quality that’s at instances mesmerizing, with all its CGI-heavy glory. Nonetheless, you’ll be able to’t assist however really feel that “Memory” at instances chokes on an extra of cheaply made environment, particularly via its bloated third act with varied overcrowded storylines of aspect characters—Cliff Curtis’ corrupt police officer Cyrus Boothe and Daniel Wu’s drug lord Saint Joe amongst them.
Maybe the best crime of “Memory” is how effortlessly it wastes the collective enchantment of its A-list forged. Within the aftermath, you may be hard-pressed to recall whether or not Bannister was performed by a bona fide film star or an unremarkable newcomer. Pleasure has a wealth of stylistic and thematic concepts to spare—let’s hope that she retains taking dangers and making feature-length motion pictures—however this explicit rumination on an assortment of genres sadly sinks underneath its personal weight.
Now enjoying in theaters and out there for 30 days on HBO Max.