Decagon House Murders – GN 2 Review

adminOctober 18, 2021Views 46

After which there “Decagon House Murders” have been six…and shortly thereafter 5. The countdown has very a lot begun for the scholars on Tsunojima, and in the event, you did not know prior to now that creator Yukito Ayatsuji took a number of his inspiration for the unique novel from Agatha Christie’s seminal 1939 novel And Then There Have been None, that ought to be very clear from this second on. Actually, that is partly as a result of the countdown has begun, with Orczy’s homicide on the finish of the primary quantity being found at the beginning of this one, however, there’s extra to it than that: in Christie’s novel, persons are picked off in a really particular order, primarily based not simply on the “Ten Little Soldier Boys” poem (or “Ten Little [racial slurs],” relying on how outdated a version you learn), but additionally on perceptions of their guilt.

Decagon House Murders

This makes one of many options of the manga not current within the unique novel a very attention-grabbing addition to the story. Whereas Ayatsuji’s e-book is primarily informed from an extra omniscient viewpoint, it does often delve into the minds of Conan and Ellery, however probably not any of the opposite characters, or no less than not on a significant degree. Hiro Kiyohara’s adaptation, nevertheless, permits us into Orczy’s reminiscences, most particularly her reminiscences of Chiori, the membership member who perished in a (manga-exclusive) boating accident. Chiori’s demise is the central drive around which all different occasions within the novel are formed, one thing quantity one allow us to in on by not solely introducing the truth that she had died throughout a membership exercise, but added that she was born on Tsunojima and that her reclusive architect father constructed each building on it – the Decagon Home and the Blue Mansion, the place he lived till his demise with everybody else within the constructing. This means that there’s a persistent hyperlink to Chiori, one which impacts every of the membership members in another way. It’s this hyperlink that flashbacks and viewpoint shifts start to actually discover on this quantity as we see how necessary Chiori was to Orczy earlier than her drowning.

Whereas I’d hesitate to say that the characters within the supply novel aren’t properly written or developed, it does really feel just like the manga model goes the additional mile for just a few of them. Particularly, we get a significantly better sense of Orczy as an individual, and that it comes after we already know she’s lifeless provides to the creepy melancholy of the story as an entire. Orczy, who first met Chiori within the college eating corridor, was capable of finding the power to come back out of her shell as a result of Chiori reached out to her; the truth is, each girl joined the Thriller Membership within the first place as a result of it was Chiori’s thought. This actually makes Chiori’s demise on a membership outing extra tragic, nevertheless, it additionally exhibits to us how nice an effect she was on Orczy, whereas additionally offering her with a motive for happening the journey within the first place. Whereas we might argue that members like Ellery went to the island as a type of homicide tourism, Orczy has gone to attempt to really feel near her lifeless buddy one final time. She’s there to mourn, to not play homicide video games. That signifies that her demise coming first – and occurring in her sleep – is supposed to point out to us that she bears the least guilt in Chiori’s passing; she actually cared concerning the different lady and whereas she was concerned about her demise (just by advantage of being current, maybe) and subsequently should die, she does not must endure – or no less than not as a lot as a few of the others by the assassin’s reckoning.

The query of who the assassin is typed one other hyperlink to Christie’s novel, which additionally takes place on a distant, remote island. Inside the closed forged there, a query arises as to if or not another person could possibly be on-island, choosing individuals off, and the characters on this collection aren’t thriller buffs for nothing – the truth is two of them are named for authors of formative locked-room tales. (Leroux, for Gaston Leroux, is the opposite; The Thriller of the Yellow Room is a locked-room traditional.) Ellery can also be properly conscious of the truth that Chiori’s father was the form of the architect who loved placing secret chambers and passages into the buildings he designs, which supplies loads of gas to the concept somebody might, the truth is, be hiding someplace else on the island. In the meantime over on the mainland, Shimada and Conan are asking round about Tsunojima, and Shimada mentions that Chiori’s father’s face was destroyed after his demise. That, mixed with the lacking gardener, might imply that if there may be one other particular person on the island, it could possibly be Mr. Nakajima – and he’d have a reasonably good motive to need the Thriller Membership members lifeless.

There are holes in this concept, in fact. The main one is that when Orczy remembers Chiori’s funeral, she notes that her father wasn’t there. Whereas this might imply that he was too prostrated by grief to attend, it additionally might imply that he merely did not care sufficient, which works in opposition to the concept he is the killer. The younger fisherman Conan talks to can also be delightfully pragmatic about all of the rumors about Tsunojima, deflating a number of her budding theories and making it seem to be the killer is, the truth is, a membership member. Not that both of our pair of mainland detectives know that there is an assassin, however, Conan has clearly learned sufficient mysteries that she’s involved in that her former clubmates might not be protected.

She’s not sporting that 221B jacket for nothing, neither is Ellery named after one of many greats of the honest play detective style to be tossing out empty theories like confetti. There’s one thing foul afoot on Tsunojima. The one query is whether or not our detectives have the time to determine it out.

Leave a comment

Name *
Add a display name
Email *
Your email address will not be published